The future of the partnership agreement between Algeria and the European Union in light of national, regional, and global developments

I. Introduction

The partnership agreement between Algeria and the European Union (EU) represents a fundamental pillar of the relationship between these two geopolitical entities. Signed in 2002 and implemented in 2005, this agreement falls within the broader framework of the European Neighborhood Policy, aiming to strengthen political, economic, and socio-cultural ties between Algeria and the EU. However, nearly two decades after its implementation, the agreement finds itself at a critical crossroads, facing numerous complex challenges arising from significant changes within Algeria, a volatile regional context, and a rapidly evolving global order.

This study seeks to analyze the future of the Algeria-EU partnership agreement in light of these multidimensional developments. It aims to address several crucial questions: How do internal transformations within Algeria and the EU affect the dynamics of their partnership? To what extent do regional turbulences in the Maghreb and the Sahel influence the priorities and modalities of cooperation? How do global challenges, such as economic crises, pandemics, or climate change, redefine the scope and objectives of this agreement?

The main objective of this research is to assess the relevance and viability of the partnership agreement in this changing context while identifying opportunities for strengthening and necessary adjustments to ensure its sustainability and effectiveness. This analysis will draw on a multidisciplinary approach, combining historical, political, economic, and legal perspectives, to provide a comprehensive overview of the issues and future prospects of this strategic partnership.

II. History and Framework of the Partnership Agreement

A. Genesis and Evolution of Algeria-EU Relations

The relationship between Algeria and the European Union is rooted in a long history of interactions, marked by periods of cooperation and tension. These relations have been deeply influenced by the colonial legacy, post-independence dynamics, and regional and global geopolitical developments.

In the 1970s, Algeria and the European Economic Community (EEC) established cooperation agreements primarily focused on trade and technical assistance (Darbouche, 2011). These initial agreements already reflected Algeria’s strategic importance to Europe, particularly as an energy supplier.

The 1990s, characterized by Algeria’s civil war, saw a relative cooling of relations, although the EU maintained its economic engagement. This period also coincided with the launch of the Barcelona Process in 1995, aimed at creating a broader framework for cooperation between the EU and Mediterranean countries (Bicchi, 2007).

It was in this context that negotiations for a more ambitious association agreement between Algeria and the EU began in 1997. These negotiations, which lasted five years, culminated in the signing of the partnership agreement in 2002 (Officially: Euro-Mediterranean Agreement Establishing an Association between the European Community and its Member States, of the one part, and the People’s Democratic Republic of Algeria, of the other part).

B. Content and Objectives of the Partnership Agreement

The Algeria-EU partnership agreement, which came into effect in 2005, is structured around three main pillars:

1. Political Dialogue and Security: The agreement aims to strengthen political dialogue between the parties, promote regional stability, and enhance cooperation on security, particularly in combating terrorism and organized crime (Article 3 of the Agreement).
2. Economic and Trade Cooperation: One of the major objectives is the gradual establishment of a free trade area, with the liberalization of trade in goods, services, and capital. The agreement also provides for cooperation in various economic sectors, including energy, transport, and the environment (Articles 6 to 46).
3. Social and Cultural Cooperation: This pillar includes provisions on the movement of people, intercultural dialogue, education, and vocational training (Articles 67 to 78).

Overall, the agreement aims to promote Algeria’s economic and social development, support its reform and modernization efforts, and strengthen regional integration (Preamble of the Agreement).

C. Implementation Review of the Agreement

After more than 15 years of implementation, the review of the Algeria-EU partnership agreement presents a mixed picture:

Economically, trade between Algeria and the EU has increased, but in an imbalanced manner. The EU remains Algeria’s largest trading partner, but Algerian exports are still dominated by hydrocarbons, while imports from the EU have diversified (Observatory of Economic Complexity, 2021).

The establishment of the free trade area has been delayed and remains partial. Algeria has expressed concerns about the impact on its domestic industry, leading to protective measures and requests to renegotiate certain aspects of the agreement (Sereni, 2020).

In terms of political and security cooperation, progress has been made, particularly in combating terrorism and managing migration flows. However, divergences persist on some regional issues and approaches to human rights (Ammour, 2018).

Social and cultural cooperation has seen advances but remains below expectations, particularly concerning the mobility of people and academic exchanges (Mebtoul, 2020).

This mixed outcome can be partly explained by the internal challenges faced by both Algeria and the EU during this period, as well as the evolving regional and global context. These factors have influenced the priorities and capacities of each party to fully implement the agreement’s provisions.

In conclusion, the Algeria-EU partnership agreement, despite its initial ambitions, has not fully met the expectations of both parties. The changes in the national, regional, and global environment have significantly impacted its implementation and effectiveness. The following sections of this study will analyze these changes in detail and their impact on the future of the agreement.

III. The Changing Algerian National Environment

A. Political and Institutional Changes

Since the signing of the partnership agreement with the EU, Algeria has undergone significant political and institutional transformations that have directly impacted the implementation and future prospects of this agreement.

The “Hirak,” a popular protest movement that began in February 2019, marked a major turning point in Algerian political life. This movement, which led to the resignation of President Abdelaziz Bouteflika after 20 years in power, ushered in a period of political instability but also of openness and democratic renewal (Serres, 2019). The Hirak’s demands for greater transparency, democracy, and the fight against corruption have had repercussions on the country’s governance and, by extension, its international relations, including with the EU.

The 2020 constitutional revision introduced significant changes to the Algerian political system, including strengthening the separation of powers and introducing new provisions on transparency and anti-corruption measures (Constitution of the People’s Democratic Republic of Algeria, 2020). These institutional changes have the potential to positively influence the implementation of the partnership agreement, particularly in areas of political cooperation and the rule of law.

However, these changes also come with challenges. Political stability remains fragile, and tensions between reform aspirations and resistance to change persist. This situation may affect Algeria’s ability to fully engage in certain aspects of the partnership agreement, particularly those related to economic reforms and trade liberalization.

B. Economic and Social Transformations

The Algerian economy has undergone significant changes since the implementation of the partnership agreement. The country has made efforts to diversify its economy, long dominated by the hydrocarbons sector, but progress remains limited.

The drop in oil prices since 2014 has highlighted the vulnerability of the Algerian economy and emphasized the need for structural reforms (IMF, 2018). This situation has directly impacted the trade balance with the EU and sparked debates on the balance of benefits from the partnership agreement.

The Algerian authorities have launched several initiatives to stimulate private investment and improve the business climate, notably through the 2020 Finance Law, which eased the 51/49 rule for foreign investments in certain sectors (Official Gazette of the People’s Democratic Republic of Algeria, 2019). These measures could promote better integration of Algeria into the Euro-Mediterranean economic space, in line with the objectives of the partnership agreement.

Socially, Algeria faces significant challenges, including high unemployment rates, especially among youth, and persistent inequalities (ONS, 2021). These social issues have direct implications for cooperation with the EU, particularly in terms of vocational training, education, and the mobility of people.

C. Energy and Environmental Issues

Algeria remains a major player in the energy sector, particularly as a supplier of natural gas to Europe. However, the Algerian energy sector faces significant challenges, such as declining production from mature fields and the need for massive investments in exploration and production (Aissaoui, 2016).

Energy transition has become a crucial issue for Algeria. The country has announced ambitious goals in renewable energy, aiming to produce 27% of its electricity from renewable sources by 2030 (Ministry of Energy, 2020). This transition offers new opportunities for cooperation with the EU under the partnership agreement, particularly in terms of technology transfer and investments.

Environmental issues, especially the fight against climate change and desertification, have become priorities for Algeria. The country has ratified the Paris Agreement on climate change and committed to reducing its greenhouse gas emissions (UNFCCC, 2015). These commitments open new avenues for cooperation with the EU under the partnership agreement, particularly in environmental protection and sustainable development.

IV. The Regional Context: Challenges and Opportunities

A. Political and Security Instability in the Maghreb and the Sahel

The regional context in which the Algeria-EU partnership agreement operates is marked by persistent instability, particularly in the Maghreb and the Sahel-Saharan region. This instability has direct implications for the implementation and priorities of the agreement.

The ongoing Libyan crisis, which has persisted since 2011, has had significant repercussions on regional security and migration flows. Algeria, sharing a long border with Libya, has been directly affected by this situation (Lounnas, 2018). Resolving this crisis has become a major issue for Algeria-EU cooperation in regional security.

In the Sahel, the rise of violent extremism and the fragility of states have created a chronically unstable region. Algeria, drawing on its experience in combating terrorism, plays a key role in regional stabilization efforts (Zoubir, 2020). This situation has reinforced the

security dimension of the partnership agreement with the EU, particularly in terms of counterterrorism and the prevention of violent extremism.

These regional crises have also impacted migration flows, with Algeria becoming a transit country for migrants from sub-Saharan Africa. The management of migration flows has become a central issue in Algeria-EU relations, with significant implications for the partnership agreement, particularly in terms of cooperation on border management and the fight against human trafficking (Lahlou, 2017).

B. Regional Economic Integration: Opportunities for Cooperation

Despite regional instability, economic integration within the Maghreb remains a key objective for Algeria and the EU. However, progress in this area has been slow, hindered by political tensions, especially between Algeria and Morocco, and structural economic challenges.

Nevertheless, the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), launched in 2021, offers new opportunities for Algeria’s regional integration and its partnership with the EU (AU, 2021). By strengthening its economic ties with sub-Saharan Africa, Algeria can enhance its position as a regional hub and create synergies with the EU, particularly in trade and investment.

In this context, the partnership agreement with the EU could play a crucial role in supporting Algeria’s efforts to integrate into the AfCFTA and, more broadly, into the global economy. This could involve enhanced cooperation in infrastructure development, support for SMEs, and the promotion of regional value chains.

C. Mediterranean Cooperation and the Union for the Mediterranean

The Union for the Mediterranean (UfM), launched in 2008, provides a broader framework for cooperation between the EU and Mediterranean countries, including Algeria. The UfM aims to promote regional integration, sustainable development, and political dialogue (UfM, 2020).

Algeria’s participation in UfM initiatives, particularly in areas such as energy, water management, and climate change, complements the objectives of the bilateral partnership agreement with the EU. However, the impact of UfM projects on Algeria has been relatively limited, and there is potential to strengthen this cooperation.

In conclusion, the regional context presents both challenges and opportunities for the Algeria-EU partnership agreement. Political and security instability in the Maghreb and the Sahel creates challenges for cooperation, particularly in terms of security and migration management. However, regional economic integration initiatives and Mediterranean cooperation frameworks offer opportunities to strengthen and diversify the partnership.

The next section will analyze the impact of global challenges on the partnership agreement and identify the necessary adjustments to ensure its sustainability and relevance.

V. Global Challenges and Their Impact on the Partnership Agreement

A. Economic Crises and Their Repercussions on the Agreement

Global economic crises, such as the 2008 financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic, have had significant impacts on the Algeria-EU partnership agreement, particularly in the areas of trade, investment, and economic cooperation.

The 2008 financial crisis led to a contraction in European demand for Algerian hydrocarbons, highlighting the vulnerabilities of the Algerian economy’s dependence on this sector (IMF, 2009). This situation underscored the need for greater economic diversification and the importance of strengthening cooperation with the EU in other sectors, such as industry and services.

The COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated these challenges, with a sharp decline in global oil prices and disruptions to global trade. The pandemic also highlighted the need for greater resilience in global supply chains, which could open up new opportunities for cooperation between Algeria and the EU in areas such as digitalization and innovation (OECD, 2020).

These economic crises have also impacted Algeria-EU relations in terms of development cooperation. The need to address the social and economic consequences of these crises has led to a re-evaluation of priorities, with a greater focus on social protection, public health, and inclusive economic growth.

B. Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Climate change presents a major challenge for the Algeria-EU partnership agreement, with significant implications for both parties. Algeria, as a country vulnerable to the effects of climate change, faces challenges such as water scarcity, desertification, and the need for sustainable energy solutions (UNDP, 2020).

The partnership agreement provides a framework for cooperation on environmental issues, but there is potential to strengthen this cooperation in light of the growing urgency of climate action. This could involve enhanced support for Algeria’s renewable energy transition, capacity building in environmental management, and joint efforts to address the impacts of climate change on vulnerable communities.

The EU’s Green Deal, which aims to make Europe the first climate-neutral continent by 2050, also presents opportunities for Algeria-EU cooperation. Algeria could benefit from EU expertise and financing in areas such as energy efficiency, sustainable agriculture, and biodiversity conservation.

C. Technological Change and Digital Transformation

Technological change and digital transformation are reshaping the global economy and have significant implications for the Algeria-EU partnership agreement. Algeria has made efforts to develop its digital infrastructure and promote innovation, but challenges remain in terms of digital inclusion and the development of a knowledge-based economy (World Bank, 2021).

The partnership agreement provides a framework for cooperation in science and technology, but there is potential to expand this cooperation to include digital transformation. This could involve joint initiatives to support digital skills development, promote e-commerce, and enhance cybersecurity.

The EU’s Digital Compass, which sets out the EU’s digital ambitions for 2030, presents opportunities for Algeria to align its digital transformation efforts with European standards and best practices. This could enhance Algeria’s competitiveness and integration into the global digital economy.

In conclusion, global challenges such as economic crises, climate change, and technological transformation have significant implications for the Algeria-EU partnership agreement. To ensure its sustainability and relevance, the agreement must be adapted to address these challenges and seize new opportunities for cooperation.

VI. Prospects for the Future of the Algeria-EU Partnership Agreement

A. Adapting the Agreement to the New Context

The changing national, regional, and global contexts require a re-evaluation and adaptation of the Algeria-EU partnership agreement. This involves not only addressing the challenges identified in the previous sections but also seizing new opportunities for cooperation.

One of the key areas for adaptation is the economic dimension of the agreement. Given the structural challenges facing the Algerian economy and the evolving global economic landscape, there is a need to reassess the trade and investment provisions of the agreement. This could involve greater flexibility in the implementation of trade liberalization commitments, enhanced support for Algeria’s economic diversification efforts, and the promotion of sustainable and inclusive economic growth.

In the area of political and security cooperation, there is potential to strengthen the partnership in response to the growing challenges of regional instability and global security threats. This could involve enhanced cooperation on counterterrorism, border management, and migration, as well as support for Algeria’s efforts to promote regional stability and conflict resolution.

Environmental cooperation is another area where the agreement could be strengthened, particularly in light of the growing urgency of climate action. This could involve enhanced support for Algeria’s renewable energy transition, joint efforts to address the impacts of climate change, and cooperation on sustainable development.

Finally, the digital dimension of the partnership agreement could be expanded to include new areas of cooperation in technology, innovation, and digital transformation. This could enhance Algeria’s competitiveness in the global digital economy and promote greater integration with the EU in these areas.

B. Strengthening Bilateral Dialogue and Consultation Mechanisms

To ensure the successful adaptation and implementation of the partnership agreement, it is essential to strengthen bilateral dialogue and consultation mechanisms between Algeria and the EU. This involves not only enhancing existing mechanisms but also creating new platforms for dialogue and cooperation.

One of the key areas for strengthening dialogue is the political and security dimension of the partnership. This could involve regular high-level consultations on regional and global security issues, as well as enhanced cooperation on counterterrorism, border management, and migration.

In the economic sphere, there is potential to strengthen dialogue on trade and investment issues, particularly in the context of Algeria’s economic diversification efforts and the global economic challenges identified earlier. This could involve regular consultations on trade and investment policies, as well as enhanced cooperation on economic reforms and development.

Environmental and digital cooperation are also areas where dialogue could be strengthened, particularly in light of the growing importance of these issues for both Algeria and the EU. This could involve regular consultations on environmental and digital policies, as well as enhanced cooperation on technology transfer, capacity building, and joint projects.

C. Promoting Greater Involvement of Civil Society and the Private Sector

The successful implementation of the Algeria-EU partnership agreement requires not only government-to-government cooperation but also the active involvement of civil society and the private sector. This involves creating opportunities for these stakeholders to participate in the design, implementation, and monitoring of the agreement.

In the economic sphere, promoting greater involvement of the private sector is essential for achieving the objectives of the partnership agreement. This could involve creating platforms for dialogue between businesses in Algeria and the EU, promoting joint ventures and partnerships, and enhancing support for SMEs and entrepreneurship.

In the area of political and social cooperation, promoting greater involvement of civil society is essential for ensuring the inclusiveness and sustainability of the partnership. This could involve creating platforms for dialogue between civil society organizations in Algeria and the EU, promoting joint initiatives on human rights, democracy, and social inclusion, and enhancing support for capacity building and advocacy.

In conclusion, the future of the Algeria-EU partnership agreement depends on its ability to adapt to the changing national, regional, and global contexts. This requires not only addressing the challenges identified in this study but also seizing new opportunities for cooperation and promoting greater involvement of all stakeholders. By doing so, the partnership can continue to serve as a cornerstone of Algeria-EU relations and contribute to the stability, prosperity, and development of both parties.

VII. Conclusion

The Algeria-EU partnership agreement has been a fundamental pillar of relations between Algeria and the European Union since its implementation in 2005. However, the evolving national, regional, and global contexts have created new challenges and opportunities for this partnership, requiring a re-evaluation and adaptation of the agreement.

The analysis in this study highlights the need

for a more flexible and responsive approach to the implementation of the partnership agreement, taking into account the specific needs and priorities of Algeria. This includes addressing the structural challenges facing the Algerian economy, promoting sustainable and inclusive economic growth, and strengthening cooperation in areas such as security, migration, environment, and digital transformation.

Moreover, the successful implementation of the partnership agreement requires the active involvement of all stakeholders, including government, civil society, and the private sector. By promoting greater dialogue, consultation, and cooperation, the Algeria-EU partnership can continue to serve as a cornerstone of relations between the two parties and contribute to the stability, prosperity, and development of both Algeria and the European Union.

The prospects for the future of the Algeria-EU partnership agreement are promising, provided that both parties remain committed to adapting the agreement to the changing context and seizing new opportunities for cooperation. In doing so, the partnership can continue to play a vital role in supporting Algeria’s development and its integration into the global economy while contributing to the broader objectives of peace, stability, and prosperity in the Mediterranean region and beyond.

VIII. REFERENCES

Achy, L. (2020). Algeria’s Economy: The Vicious Circle of Oil Dependency. Carnegie Middle East Center.

Aghrout, A. (2015). Algeria-EU Trade Relations: Challenges and Prospects. Mediterranean Politics, 20(1), 132-149.

Aissaoui, A. (2016). Algerian Gas: Troubling Trends, Troubled Policies. Oxford Institute for Energy Studies.

Ammour, L. A. (2018). L’Algérie et la sécurité au Sahel : quel rôle et quelle stratégie ? Fondation pour la Recherche Stratégique.

Bensaâd, A. (2016). L’immigration subsaharienne en Algérie : un enjeu politique et sociétal. Confluences Méditerranée, 97(2), 101-116.

Bicchi, F. (2007). European Foreign Policy Making Toward the Mediterranean. Palgrave Macmillan.

Collyer, M. (2016). Geopolitics as a migration governance strategy: European Union bilateral relations with Southern Mediterranean countries. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 42(4), 606-624.

Commission européenne. (2020). Communication conjointe au Parlement européen, au Conseil européen, au Conseil, au Comité économique et social européen et au Comité des régions : Réaction face au coronavirus dans le voisinage méridional.

Darbouche, H. (2011). Third Time Lucky? Euro-Mediterranean Energy Co-operation under the Union for the Mediterranean. Mediterranean Politics, 16(1), 193-211.

Darbouche, H. (2018). Energising EU-Algerian Relations. In A. Boubekeur & L. Martinez (Eds.), The Maghreb-Europe Relationship: A New Start? (pp. 87-104). Routledge.

Darbouche, H., & Zoubir, Y. H. (2017). The Algerian-European Partnership: The Failure of a Model of North-South Cooperation? In Y. H. Zoubir & G. White (Eds.), North African Politics: Change and Continuity (pp. 202-219). Routledge.

Escribano, G. (2016). The Impact of Low Oil Prices on Algeria. Center for Strategic and International Studies.

Escribano, G. (2017). The Shrinking Euro-Mediterranean Policy Space. ARI 69/2017, Real Instituto Elcano.

FMI. (2018). Algeria : 2018 Article IV Consultation-Press Release; Staff Report; and Statement by the Executive Director for Algeria. IMF Country Report No. 18/168.

GIEC. (2014). Changements climatiques 2014 : Rapport de synthèse.

Hernando de Larramendi, M. (2019). Doomed regionalism in a redrawn Maghreb? The changing shape of the rivalry between Algeria and Morocco in the post-2011 era. The Journal of North African Studies, 24(3), 506-531.

Issaev, L., & Shishkina, A. (2020). Russia in the Middle East: In Search of its Place. In E. Lannon (Ed.), The Middle East and North Africa: 2019-2020 (pp. 255-267). Routledge.

Lons, C., Fulton, J., Sun, D., & Al-Tamimi, N. (2019). China’s Great Game in the Middle East. European Council on Foreign Relations.

Lounnas, D. (2018). The Libyan Security Continuum: The Impact of the Libyan Crisis on the North African/Sahelian Regional System. MENARA Working Papers, No. 15.

Lounnas, D. (2020). L’Algérie face au défi jihadiste au Sahel. Politique étrangère, 85(2), 127-139.

Mebtoul, A. (2020). L’économie algérienne face aux défis de la mondialisation. L’Harmattan.

Ministère de la Défense Nationale. (2021). Rapport sur la sécurité maritime en Méditerranée.

Ministère de l’Énergie. (2020). Programme national des énergies renouvelables.

OCDE. (2019). Examens de l’OCDE des politiques de transformation numérique : Examens par pays.

OIM. (2020). Rapport sur les migrations en Afrique du Nord.

ONS. (2021). Activité, Emploi & Chômage En Septembre 2020. Office National des Statistiques.

Sereni, J-P. (2020). Algérie-UE : un partenariat en quête de renouveau. Orient XXI.

Serres, T. (2019). Understanding Algeria’s 2019 Revolutionary Movement. Middle East Brief, No. 127, Crown Center for Middle East Studies.

Tagliapietra, S. (2018). The Euro-Mediterranean Energy Relationship: A Fresh Perspective. Policy Brief, Bruegel.

Thieux, L. (2018). Le rôle de la société civile dans les relations euro-méditerranéennes. IEMed Mediterranean Yearbook 2018.

UA. (2019). Agreement Establishing the African Continental Free Trade Area.

UNFCCC. (2015). Accord de Paris.

Van de Graaf, T., Overland, I., Scholten, D., & Westphal, K. (2020). The new oil? The geopolitics and international governance of hydrogen. Energy Research & Social Science, 70, 101667.

Youngs, R. (2020). The EU’s Strategic Autonomy Trap. Carnegie Europe.

Zoubir, Y. H. (2018). Algeria’s Role in the Sahelian Security Crisis. Stability: International Journal of Security and Development, 7(1), 1-16.

Zoubir, Y. H. (2020). Algerian-American Relations: Conflict, Cooperation, and Pragmatism. In R. Mason (Ed.), Reassessing Order and Disorder in the Middle East: Regional Imbalance or Disintegration? (pp. 215-236). Rowman & Littlefield.